TPMS Light

I recently broke off the valve stem on my OEM TPMS sensor. Had to remove the wheel and take it to shop where they installed a new one.
Took the wheel home and reinstalled and today took it by the shop to program it.
The TPMS light in the dash has been on since I reinstalled the wheel. Now that they programmed it, it is still staying on.
They showed me that the truck is seeing all four sensors, minus the spare, but it’s never had a spare and the light was never on before.
I’ve tried resetting the system with the reset button, but it never flashes three times for me.
Am I missing anything?

 

I'm trying to remember when I had my 2013. IIRC, you have to push and hold it until it flashes. Is the tire pressure in that tire high enough to be over the minimum pressure setting for the light?

 

I’m running around 34lbs. Sticker in door says 30 for front and 33 for rear.

I tried holding that button in, with the ignition on but the engine not running per instructions.