toyo open country AT3 vs. goodyear ultra terrain

Trying to pick between these two for my 2005 DC 4x4 ( 285/70/R17)
Any experience/input would be appreciated.

 

I would choose the Toyo AT3. Lots of good reviews about them here and other places. Good tire and believe they have a 60-65k treadwear warranty. Nice AT that will do well on road, snow, wet, etc.

The other is a discount tire exclusive, made for them by goodyear. Probably decent, I would search for reviews online. Not sure if they have any treadwear warranty however. For my $ I would go with Toyo vs goodyear.

 

I have had Toyo AT3s on for the winter here in Oregon and they’ve been great. They’ve seen a ton of rain, some snow and everything in between. My only complaint is they like to grab rocks but I don’t know of an aggressive tread that doesn’t grab rock.

 

Toyo AT3’s all the way!

 

My AT3 were noisy, would not choose them again personally.

 

Have personal experiences with the Goodyears. They are great off road and have good road manners. They have a small hum but not terrible. I personally like the BFG KO2’s for the mileage warranty and they perform well.

 

Thanks for the input folks, last fall we put the Toyo's on our 4runner and have been happy with them.
The Ultra Terrain's are about $50/tire cheaper so that's why they are being considered. Perhaps I should also be looking at the Wildpeak At3's, I have them on my Taco and have been fairly happy with them.

 

I just got the Cooper AT3 XLTs and like them a lot. No road noise at 90 mph, great in the rain, and they look aggressive enough. I know these weren't part of the OP, but I did a ton of research that included the Wildpeaks so maybe it helps ya.

 

500 miles on my AT3's so far so good

 

I have almost 2k miles on my Toyo AT3's and love them so far. They look great and perform even better. Surprised with how smooth and quiet they are for a tire that aggressive.