Best 35x12.5r20

Hello all. My truck has 35x12.5r20 Falken Wildpeak AT3Ws currently, and I'm shopping around for replacements (current rubber is 5-1/2 years old, and beginning to look a bit dry-rotted).

Truck is a daily driver and doesn't really go offroad. Priorities are good winter weather performance, and "quiet-ish" at highway speeds. If I go 11.5" in width and gain an MPG (and save $30 a tire), that'd be a nice bonus.

Just looking for recommendations as to the best value All-Terrain tire in a 35x11.5r20, or 35x12.5r20 size.

P.S. - I should mention that I've had constant struggles keeping the current AT3Ws balanced and they seem to go out of balance quickly after getting balanced. I'd really like to solve that with the new replacements too.

Pic of the truck as it sits on the AT3Ws:

 

Lots of good info in here and might be worth posting the question there.

https://www.tundras.com/forums/wheels-tires.18/

 

I went with BFG KO2. Quiet on the road. "Best" is subjective. My off-road is the beach once in awhile...other than that it's on the road.

 

What width are you running? 11.5" or 12.5"?

I have K02s on my Tacoma and they really are great tires. Definitely may consider them

 

12.5 for the width on the beach.