Should I Buy a 2019 Tundra for $51K or a 2025 Tundra?

Pretty expensive for that model/year as all have pointed out. I guess I'll never understand the "is this a good deal?" forum approval-seeking behavior. Everyone appreciates a good deal, but it's relative. If you can afford the $51k and you've been jonesing for a 2.5gen pro.. get it, and drive the H, E, Double-L Hockey Sticks out of it for the next 15 years.

If the oil thing worries you, have the owner take it to a shop they trust to change the oil, pay the $60-100 whatever it costs these days, and send the oil to one of the testing labs (Blackstone, AMSOIL, etc) and see what they have to say about it.

 

Thats a lot of money for a 2019. Ive seen 2021s in that price tag. You can buy my LSK long travel truck for less.

 

Make him an offer and see if he bites. At 51K, despite the low mileage, that price is going to scare a lot of people off. Get the oil analyzed before you make the offer though.

 

Biased here, but I'd look at other 2.5 gen options. There are a lot of trucks out there that have low miles at lower prices. The money you save can be used to upgrade your suspension if that's why you want the pro.