Sticking with Toyo ATIIIs or moving to the AT3 XLT?

I currently have Toyo ATIII's and have been fairly happy with them other than the price point. Unfortunately, I suffered a sidewall gash in one and two others have developed slow leaks. Discount honored the tire warranty for all three, so I'm just going to replace them all. I like the looks of the Toyos, rain performance isn't great, and tread life was okay. They are currently one of the most expensive options, and there is a closeout on the Cooper AT3 XLTs. Reviews are mixed on these however with some people swearing by them, and others saying they were awful to balance, and tread life was also not great. I'm willing to pay the price point for the Toyo's if they are still on of the best all around options. I do a lot of highway driving daily, so both of these are probably overkill, but I just like the more aggressive style even if it's not the most practical. I do live on a large piece of ground and have a 1/2 mile long driveway, so I'm "offroad" a lot between my property and my cabin, so that's how I justify it. Anyways, would love you hear everyone's opinion on these two (or I suppose any other similar tire in this category that I may not be giving the time of day to and should be).

Thanks!

 

General Grabber A/TX. As aggressive as KO2, less noisy. Have sipings = better in rain and winter. The least expensive option, I think. Can be hard to balance, but that's what warranty is for. My new set balanced perfectly, no vibration up to 90.